Paul Gillin's blog

has been moved to new address

http://www.devilsworkshop.org

Sorry for the inconvenience...

Paul Gillin's Blog - Social Media and the Open Enterprise: October 2005
Paul Gillin's Blog - Social Media and the Open Enterprise
Thursday, October 27, 2005
  Why good companies fail
IT Conversations has a fascinating podcast by Clayton Christensen, the Harvard Business School professor and author of the best-selling book The Innovator's Dilemma. Speaking at the Open Source Business Conference 2004, Christensen explains why well-managed companies with superior products are sometimes beaten by startups with inferior products. The basic reason: if the product is "good enough" for a large group of customers who didn't have access to that kind of functionality before, the customers will adopt it and stay with it while the product improves rather than go with the expensive, over-engineered alternatives from the industry leaders.

The PC, of course, is the best example of this. But it applies to so many tech innovations: LANs, PDAs, cell phones, open source....When you think of it, none of those products were particularly good at the outset but people loved them because they could do something that they couldn't have done before. And they stuck with them while they matured.

Listen to the podcast. It's great.
 
Sunday, October 23, 2005
  More marketing myopia
It's been a long time between posts because of a process known as 2006 strategic planning, which at my company is a grueling analysis of the year's results and likely progress in the next year. It's an important and worthwhile exercise but it saps a lot of time.

I'll rant a bit today about C-level myopia or computer marketing professionals' hyperfocus on the top level of the IT organization. It's one of the most frustrating aspects of IT marketing and, I believe, a significant impediment to many companies' success. I hear this time and again in talks with vendors: they want to reach the CIO. But few of the companies who say that have a chance of getting on the CIO's radar. And even if they did, it's doubtful that would do much good for their businesses.

There's no question that CIOs are critical influencers in IT buying but you have to put their role in perspective. Most large organizations have IT budgets in the millions of dollars. At the very biggest, that number can be over a billion dollars. The CIO's role in these companies is to align IT with business strategy: know where the organization is going and how technology can support those goals. This business focus is becoming more and more critical to the CIO role. As it should. CIOs have less and less time to concern themselves with the specific vendors and products.

Product selection is increasingly being delegated to the lower levels of the organization. This only makes sense in markets that are competitive and in which the core feature sets of most products are similar. Technology selection has become an increasingly complex process because choices are made based on nuances such as vertical market features, support, price and vendor viability.

In a typical IT organization, the CIO is responsible for setting strategic direction, managing a budget, identifying approved vendors and signing off on purchase decisions. However, the process of researching and identifying the vendors who will provide new products and services is largely delegated to the people who will work with those products and vendors. IT is becoming more specialized, which means that the specialists are the ones who make the most critical decisions. They decide which products and vendors to recommend to the CIO and it is their reasoning and research that most influences a selection. CIOs don't have the time or expertise to dig into these questions. In fact, smart CIOs know that if they did try to micro-manage every decision, they would make worse choices because they don't know as much about the market or technology as the people below them.

That's why nearly every CIO I've spoken to has said that hiring good people is one of his/her biggest challenges. The CIO's job is too big and complex not to require good delegating skills.

CIOs do play a critical role in signing off on the purchase which is where visibility and relationships come in. It's important that these executives be familiar and comfortable with the vendors they align themselves with. That's where brand advertising works.

But vendors who just target the CIO are missing critical influencers. The people lower in the food chain are the ones most likely to decide who gets on the short list. Few marketers get this. Savvy IT organizations go through a rigorous process of identifying needs, researching suppliers and products, developing a "short list" and choosing strategic partners. The CIO is usually involved at the beginning and end of this cycle, but rarely in the middle.

And where the technology is "disruptive" the CIO's role is even smaller. In fact, nearly every truly game-changing technology that has emerged in the enterprise landscape going back to minicomputers was brought in the back door of the organization. Think of it: the CIO's role is to maintain stability and reliability. He/she is rarely going to stir the waters with disruptive change. Technologies like PCs, cell phones, PDAs, file servers, the Internet and open source software have been successful because risk-takers at the low levels of the organization adopted them and proved their viability. Microsoft and Dell were successful in the early days because they targeted PC managers, not CIOs.

I'll post more on this as we wrap up a research study about the IT buying process.
 
How social media and open computing are changing the business world.

My Photo
Name:
Location: Framingham, Massachusetts, United States

Paul is a writer and media consultant specializing in information technology topics.

Subscribe:


Buy my book about how new media influencers are changing the rules of publishing.


Or sign up to receive a FREE PDF of my forthcoming book, Secrets of Social Media Marketing. Click the cover image below to register.

>


 Subscribe RSS

Subscribe by e-mail:



Paul Gillin Communications
I'm a writer, speaker and new media consultant. Learn more.




See my


Get my weekly social media newsletter!

Email
First Name
Last Name
Please fill all fields


View the newsletter archive.

View Paul Gillin's profile on LinkedIn


Readers of my blog get discounts for this upcoming event:

Use discount code PAULVIP to get $100 off. Hurry! Prices go up Sept. 19



Paul Gillin Communications / New Influencers book site / Mediablather - Paul Gillin & David Strom / Geocaching Secrets (my upcoming 2009 book) / Newspaper Death Watch / Paul and Dana's Blog /

    Overheard in the Blogosphere / Whatis.com blog / Dan Gillmor / Reflections of a Newsosaur / Scott Kirsner's Innovation Economy / Vincent Ferrari / BL Ochman / Katie Paine / Scott Kirsner / Tamar Weinberg / The Future of News / David Weinberger / Blogarithms / David Strom's Web Informant / Robin Good / Steve Rubel / Influencer Marketing / Debbie Weil / On the Record...Online / MarksGuide / TheNewPR/Wiki / Nicholas Carr / Henry Jenkins / Lawrence Lessig / The Society for New Communications Research / Business Blog Consulting / MetzMash / Renee Blodgett / Max Kalehoff / Dave Taylor / MarketingProfs: Daily Fix /
    BunnyBlab / Dave Barry / LifeHacker / BoingBoing / MetaFilter / WikiHow / Museum of Hoaxes / Make blog / The Onion / MilkAndCookies / News of the Weird /
    Archives
    June 2005 / July 2005 / August 2005 / September 2005 / October 2005 / November 2005 / December 2005 / January 2006 / February 2006 / March 2006 / April 2006 / May 2006 / June 2006 / July 2006 / August 2006 / September 2006 / October 2006 / November 2006 / December 2006 / January 2007 / February 2007 / March 2007 / April 2007 / May 2007 / June 2007 / July 2007 / August 2007 / September 2007 / October 2007 / November 2007 / December 2007 / January 2008 / February 2008 / March 2008 / April 2008 / May 2008 / June 2008 / July 2008 / August 2008 / September 2008 /

    Bloggeries Blog Directory

    2RSS.com :: RSS directory
    Blog Directory & Search engine Blog Directory


      follow me on Twitter

      Profile for PnD
      Add to Technorati Favorites
      Stats by: