Paul Gillin's blog

has been moved to new address

http://www.devilsworkshop.org

Sorry for the inconvenience...

Paul Gillin's Blog - Social Media and the Open Enterprise: How to avoid open-source losers
Paul Gillin's Blog - Social Media and the Open Enterprise
Sunday, February 04, 2007
  How to avoid open-source losers
InformationWeek's Charles Babcock, who's hands-down the best IT reporter in the industry press, has an outstanding cover package on open source this week. He writes about something that open-source aficianados don't like to discuss: the fact that the majority of open-source projects go nowhere, whether because of lack of user interest, developer distraction or competition from more successful alternatives.

This is a big issue for IT organizations, of course. Bet a big project on the wrong horse and you can end up wasting a ton of time and money. There are winners and losers in the commercial software world, of course, but that business has the benefit of an active media and analyst community that keeps tabs on the players. There is no such monitor in open source, although Babcock notes some fledgling projects such as FLOSSmole that are trying to provide that service. Basically, everyone's on his or her own and you take your best guess at whether the software you're adopting will be around in five years.

The piece opens with a great anecdote about an open-source project that foundered because of a legal dispute involving the company that was trying to commercialize it. Babcock goes on to relay a lot of solid advice on how to avoid mistakes. This is an innovative take on an important market issue that I haven't seen covered before.
 
Comments:
Hi Paul,

For what it's worth, I wrote a story called "Free Code for Sale: The New Business of Open Source," that looked at the growing pattern of open source developers offering parallel proprietary software to their open source code that is usually richer in functionality and updated more often--what I call "mixed source."
http://www.cio.com/archive/021506/opensource.html

Christopher Koch
Executive Editor
CIO Magazine
492 Old Connecticut Path
Framingham, MA 01701 USA
508.935.4786 (direct)
508.879.7784 (fax)
ckoch@cio.com
www.cio.com
Check out my blog "Koch's IT Strategy" at: http://blogs.cio.com/blog/10
 
Paul, I've been challenged on a number of points in that piece but I'm standing by them. I think it's worth discussing, however, whether every successful open source project has a "benevolent dictator" like Linus Torvalds. There's a more peer-based way of organizing open source projectsthan dictatorship. Thanks for your comments. Charlie
 
As open source becomes big business there will naturally be shades of gray that will develop between the free and proprietary software alternatives. Both these articles do a find job of exploring some of these emerging nuances.
 
Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]





<< Home
How social media and open computing are changing the business world.

My Photo
Name:
Location: Framingham, Massachusetts, United States

Paul is a writer and media consultant specializing in information technology topics.

Subscribe:


Buy my book about how new media influencers are changing the rules of publishing.


Or sign up to receive a FREE PDF of my forthcoming book, Secrets of Social Media Marketing. Click the cover image below to register.

>


 Subscribe RSS

Subscribe by e-mail:



Paul Gillin Communications
I'm a writer, speaker and new media consultant. Learn more.




See my


Get my weekly social media newsletter!

Email
First Name
Last Name
Please fill all fields


View the newsletter archive.

View Paul Gillin's profile on LinkedIn


Readers of my blog get discounts for this upcoming event:

Use discount code PAULVIP to get $100 off. Hurry! Prices go up Sept. 19

2RSS.com :: RSS directory
Blog Directory & Search engine Blog Directory


    follow me on Twitter

    Profile for PnD
    Add to Technorati Favorites
    Stats by: